Cheesy Chicken Pot Pie with Biscuits

Possibly our favorite comfort food of fall, this Chicken Pot Pie with Biscuits is cozy, delicious and a such fun twist on traditional chicken pot pie. We take a classic creamy pot pie filling full of chicken, carrots, celery, and potatoes and stud it with sharp cheddar cheese and then top it off with fluffy, tender cheddar chive biscuits. Heaven in a casserole dish.

For more chicken pot pie recipes, be sure to check out this Easy Chicken Pot Pie, and this Healthy Phyllo Chicken Pot Pie.

Cheesy Biscuit Chicken Pot Pie 

I’ve made chicken pot pie what seems like hundreds of times and I’ve also made it every way you can think of. I’ve mastered it classically with a flaky top and bottom crust. With huge chunks of lobster and pearl onions. Lightened up with phyllo dough and low-fat milk, just to name a few. But I have to admit, today’s Cheesy Chicken Pot Pie with biscuits is the best version yet. And honestly, the best I’ve tasted, period.

While this version doesn’t stray too far from the classic, I add an extra layer of flavor in the filling with my favorite way to make dishes a little bit more elegant – dry sherry (like in this Creamy Chicken Noodle Soup). It adds this sweet, almost luxurious taste I can’t get enough of when it’s laced with creamy sauce, veggies and perfectly cooked chicken.

Cheddar cheese is something you don’t find in most chicken pot pie fillings, but I just love the sharp cheesy flavor and texture it gives the filling. 

Also, instead of a crispy pie crust for the top layer, I whip up the flakiest, cheesiest, most delicious cheddar chive biscuits, which I nestle right on top of the filling. 

Let’s get started! 

Ingredients in our Chicken Pot Pie with Biscuits

The biscuits

Butter + shortening. My favorite way to make flavorful, flaky biscuits is to use a combination of butter for flavor and shortening, for flakiness. It’s the perfect combination because if you just use one or the other, you either get flavor or flakiness, and we want both! 

All purpose flour. Some people swear by self-rising flour but I find all-purpose flour works just fine. 

Baking powder + baking soda. Baking powder is what makes the biscuits rise. Baking soda is another leavening agent, but often needs to paired with an acid, like buttermilk to activate. 

Cheddar cheese. We use a super-sharp cheddar cheese and the sharper the better! You could also swap out the yellow cheddar for white cheddar or any other super sharp cheese. 

Buttermilk. Unless I’m making something like shortcakes which require richness, I like to use buttermilk in my biscuits. It adds tang, plus it gives the biscuits a super soft texture. 

The filling

Butter. If we’re going for it, we may as well use a little bit of butter so saute the veggies. I always try to use unsalted butter so I can control the amount of salt in the dish. 

Veggies. You could use whatever veggies you want, but I went classic in our chicken pot pie with biscuits. We use plenty of diced potato, onion, carrots, celery, and frozen peas. Other good additions would be sweet potatoes, pearl onions, or winter squash. 

Flour. We need a little bit of flour to thicken up the filling.

Chicken stock. We always use low-sodium chicken stock. Any good quality brand will work great. 

Sherry. I am obsessed with dry sherry. It gives our biscuit pot pie an elevated, luxurious taste you can’t get with anything else. (We also use it in our Healthy Chicken Tetrazzini.)

Milk. Any kind of milk will work, but we like to use whole milk. 

Chicken. You can quickly sear up some chicken or you can use rotisserie chicken as well. 

Let’s make Chicken Pot Pie with Biscuits

Cook the veggies. Sweat onion, carrot, celery and diced potato in a little bit of butter. Once the veggies are slightly soft, mix the flour in.

Make the sauce. Add in dry sherry, chicken stock and whole milk.  Bring the mixture to a boil, reduce to a simmer until it thickens up nicely. 

Add everything else. When the filling thickens, turn the heat off and add in the cheese. Stir until it’s combined. Fold in the chicken. Lastly, throw the frozen peas in. Make sure to season with salt and pepper!

Pour the filling into a casserole dish and top with the raw biscuits.

How to make the BEST homemade biscuits

Making really great homemade biscuits isn’t hard, but there are some things you need to keep in mind. 

• Fold the dough over itself to create flaky layers. This goes against what I used to think about biscuits in that the less you handle it, the better. However, I’ve found that when you continue to fold the dough over itself, the result is tall, layered biscuits that are irresistible!  
• Use cold ingredients! The shortening doesn’t need to be cold, but the butter and buttermilk do. I like to cut my butter in to cubes, separate them and then place them back in the fridge while I measure the dry ingredients and shred the cheese.
• Be quick! When using your biscuit cutter, go straight down and straight up. If you twist the dough, you may end up with lopsided biscuits.
• Use plenty of flour. Dust the biscuit cutter with plenty of flour to avoid sticking.

Do I have to make homemade biscuits??

This is a tough one for me, I say yes. Just because these biscuits are SO good! But if you are really craving a biscuit chicken pot pie when you don’t have a lot of time, refrigerated biscuits will also do the trick. 

Can I leave the cheese out? 

Sure! Just make sure the filling thickens up enough still. You can also use low-fat cheddar if you’re worried about fat and calories. But I mean, when you’re indulging, might as well go all the way!  

Substitutions and Tips and Tricks for Recipe Success

• Again, when making the biscuits work with cold ingredients! 
• Try making this with lobster or shrimp for a seafood version! 
• Add any of your favorite veggies – pearl onions, sweet potatoes, butternut squash would all be great additions. 
• You can swap out the whole milk for low-fat milk, it won’t be as creamy, but will still work! 
• For glistening biscuits, brush the tops with egg wash. 
• If you don’t have fresh herbs on top, feel free to leave them off. 
• If the biscuits start to brown a little bit too much, lower the dish to the bottom part of the oven,. 

Other comforting winter dishes

• Our Broccoli Cheddar Mac and Cheesee is the ultimate comfort food. Plus it tastes just like Panera’s Broccoli Cheddar Soup in pasta form! 
• Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup is probably my favorite thing to eat on a cold fall or winter day. Plus, it comes together in no time. 
• Stuffed Pasta Shells is another comforting dish we can’t get enough of!